Why your micromanaging boss is driving you crazy and how to confront them
The word ‘micromanager’ has become synonymous with stress and fear. It's the phenomenon where a boss or manager closely oversees and controls every aspect of their employees' work, leaving little room for autonomy or creativity.
The detrimental effects of micromanagement on employee morale, job satisfaction, and productivity are well-documented. In this blog, I want to delve into the psychology behind why some managers resort to micromanaging, and also provide actionable strategies for you to confront your boss to work towards a more balanced and productive working relationship.
Why do we still have micromanagers?
Working under a micromanager can drive anyone crazy. The reasons for your frustration can be underpinned by four psychological elements of micromanagement:
Number One: The Need for Control
At the core of micromanagement lies a deep-seated need for control. Managers who engage in micromanagement often fear the consequences of not being in control of their team's tasks and outcomes. This fear can stem from various sources, such as a lack of trust in their employees, a need to maintain a sense of power, or anxiety about the potential for mistakes. Although this is not an excuse for their behaviour, it can be helpful to understand where their need for constant monitoring comes from.
Number Two: Fear of Failure
Another psychological aspect driving micromanagement is the fear of failure. Managers who micromanage may have a perfectionist mindset and believe that only they can ensure tasks are completed flawlessly. As such, they may equate any minor mistake with personal failure. Imagine thinking that failing to deliver something on time at work was akin to failing as a parent. For them, their fear of failure occurs because they believe the failure is life-altering - and not in a good way. This is why they try to oversee every detail and attempt to avoid errors - in their minds, the consequences are too dire for failure. This fear can be exacerbated by an organisation’s pressure for high performance, or the mismanagement of insubordinate staff in the past that made them look bad.
Number Three: Lack of Trust
Just like in any relationship, trust is a cornerstone of a healthy manager-subordinate dynamic. Micromanagers often have trust issues, either with their team members' capabilities or their own ability to delegate effectively. They may believe that no one can perform the job as well as they can, leading to constant intervention and control. They might also fear that their own management skills are lacking and therefore going to lead to failure. You read that right - a lot of bad managers know they aren’t good at their jobs. For many people, management is a natural progression step in their careers. However, not everyone is suited to being a manager, and this may be something that drives someone into micromanaging tendencies.
Number Four: Communication Breakdown
Micromanagers tend to struggle with communication skills, leading to frustration on both sides. They may lack the ability to motivate, provide constructive feedback, or give clear directions. This can be because they are so focussed on doing things according to their own vision, it can be almost impossible for them to put themselves in their team’s shoes and accept that different people need different approaches from a manager. This is why they resort to closely supervising tasks rather than explaining their expectations clearly, resulting in misunderstandings and tension.
Is it time to leave your toxic manager and workplace?
Take my free Workplace Assessment and find out!
How to Confront Your Micromanaging Boss
Firstly, check in with yourself
Before confronting your manager, recognise that your goal is not to undermine them but to improve the working relationship. If you were to go in with guns blazing for revenge, you’re at risk of making the problem worse. As mentioned, a major determinant of micromanagement is a lack of trust - whether it’s warranted or not. If you were to suddenly act out of character and become hostile, it’s not going to help you begin to change their mind about trusting you.
Secondly, choose the right time and place
Timing is crucial when addressing this sensitive issue. Select a time when your boss is approachable and not under extreme stress. Request a private meeting to discuss your concerns without distractions. This demonstrates your professionalism and seriousness about the issue, whilst providing a one-on-one setting without colleagues or distractions.
Use "I" Statements
When discussing the problem, use "I" statements to express your feelings and experiences. For example, say, "I feel less motivated when I'm not given the autonomy to complete tasks on my own" instead of "You always micromanage me, and it's frustrating." This approach is less accusatory and encourages a more constructive conversation. People rarely admit their faults when they feel ambushed - especially micromanagers. Instead, use this language to indicate that it’s time for sharing and honesty.
Next, provide examples
Support your claims with specific examples of situations where their micromanagement hindered your productivity or job satisfaction. Concrete examples help your boss understand the impact of their behavior and make it easier to find solutions. If you can, refer to emails, team chats, or other documented evidence, as it can’t be disputed. Also try to remain calm and non-threatening, as presenting evidence may make your boss feel that you’re ready to go to HR. Whilst it’s well within your right to do so, solving it directly is always a better option. Remember, micromanagers often become this way due to the enormous pressure they are under, which can make them tense, forgetful, or emotional. Pulling out evidence is necessary to show you’re not to be disrespected or dismissed, but it must be done in a manner that’s as inoffensive as possible because you still have to work together.
Then, suggest alternatives
Instead of just pointing out the problem, come prepared with suggestions for alternatives. Offer to provide regular updates on your progress or set clear milestones for projects. These solutions can help your boss feel more comfortable with a less hands-on approach. It also shows that your intention is not to cause conflict, but to fix a problem so that you can get back to being productive.
If all else fails, seek mediation
If the initial conversation doesn't yield positive results, consider involving a higher-up or HR in mediating the discussion. A neutral third party can provide insights and facilitate a more constructive dialogue.
Moving forward with your micromanager
After your meeting, keep the lines of communication open with your boss. Regularly update them on your progress without waiting for them to ask. Be proactive in seeking clarification on tasks and expectations to minimise misunderstandings. This will help build trust and get them off your back. Alongside this tactic, make sure your boss understands the areas where you require autonomy and where you are open to their input.
Take the initiative to suggest improvements and innovations in your work. Prove that you can handle tasks independently and offer solutions to problems that arise.
Micromanaging bosses can be frustrating and demoralising, but understanding the psychology behind it and taking proactive steps to address the issue can lead to a more productive and harmonious work environment. Remember that confronting your micromanaging boss should be done with empathy and a focus on improving the working relationship rather than challenging their authority. By implementing the strategies outlined, you can take steps towards a healthier, more balanced professional relationship with your manager.